Personal Data & Privacy

Personal Data Retention and Disposal Policy

The principles, retention periods and disposal methods applied by Dentist Ayberk to personal data under the KVKK.

English translation notice

This English version is provided for information. In the event of any discrepancy or difference in meaning, the Turkish text shall prevail.

1. Purpose and Scope

This Personal Data Retention and Disposal Policy (the "Policy") has been prepared by Dentist Ayberk Şafak Benli (the Oral and Dental Health Practice operating under the trade name "Dentist Ayberk") (hereinafter the "Practice"), acting as Data Controller, in order to fulfil our obligations under the Personal Data Protection Law No. 6698 (the "Law") and the Regulation on the Erasure, Destruction or Anonymisation of Personal Data (the "Regulation"), which constitutes secondary legislation under the Law, and to inform Data Subjects about the principles used to determine the maximum retention period necessary for the purpose for which their personal data are processed and about the processes of erasure, destruction and anonymisation.

The Policy applies to all personal data relating to our patients, patient relatives, persons submitting appointment requests, website users, visitors, employees, job applicants, employees and authorised representatives of suppliers and business partners, and other natural persons whose data are processed by our Practice, whether processed wholly or partly by automated means or by non-automated means provided that they form part of a data filing system.

Data Controller: Dentist Ayberk Şafak Benli (Oral and Dental Health Practice operating under the trade name "Dentist Ayberk")

Address: Konacık Mahallesi, Kanuni Sultan Süleyman Caddesi, No: 17 B, Daire: 1, Bodrum / Muğla, Türkiye

Telephone: +90 542 552 45 06

Email: [email protected]

Website: dentistayberk.com

2. Definitions

Explicit Consent: freely given, specific and informed consent relating to a particular matter. Authorised User: persons who process personal data within the Data Controller's organisation, or on the basis of authority and instructions received from the Data Controller, excluding the person or unit responsible for the technical storage, protection and backup of the data. Disposal: erasure, destruction or anonymisation of personal data. Recording Medium: any environment containing personal data processed wholly or partly by automated means or by non-automated means provided that they form part of a data filing system. Personal Data: any information relating to an identified or identifiable natural person. Special Categories of Personal Data: personal data listed in Article 6 of the Law and, for our Practice, consisting primarily of patients' health data. Erasure of Personal Data: rendering personal data inaccessible and unusable in any way by Authorised Users. Destruction of Personal Data: rendering personal data inaccessible, irretrievable and unusable by anyone in any way. Anonymisation of Personal Data: rendering personal data impossible to link with an identified or identifiable natural person, even through matching them with other data. Periodic Disposal: erasure, destruction or anonymisation carried out ex officio at recurring intervals specified in the personal-data retention and disposal policy when all conditions for processing personal data under the Law have ceased to exist. HIMS: health information management system software registered in the Ministry of Health registration system. Board: Personal Data Protection Board. Data Owner / Data Subject: the natural person whose personal data are processed.

3. Principles

Our Practice acts in accordance with the following principles when retaining and disposing of personal data:

  • Erasure, destruction and anonymisation of personal data are carried out in full compliance with the Law, the Regulation, healthcare legislation, decisions of the Board and this Policy.
  • All operations relating to erasure, destruction and anonymisation of personal data are recorded, and such records are retained for at least three years, without prejudice to other legal obligations.
  • Unless the Board decides otherwise, our Practice selects the appropriate method among ex officio erasure, destruction or anonymisation; where the Data Subject makes a request, the appropriate method is selected and the reasons are explained.
  • When all conditions for processing under Articles 5 and 6 of the Law cease to exist, personal data are erased, destroyed or anonymised ex officio or at the request of the Data Subject.
  • For health data, obligations arising from healthcare legislation concerning the keeping and retention of patient records and the evidentiary interests of the dentist and the patient are taken into account. Records that must be retained by law cannot be erased at the Data Subject's request before the mandatory retention period expires, and the Data Subject is informed of this together with the reasons.
  • Where a Data Subject applies, requests are answered within no more than thirty days. If the data concerned have been transferred to third parties, the relevant third party is notified and the necessary actions are ensured at that third party.

4. Recording Media

Personal data are stored by our Practice in the following media: HIMS software and databases registered in the Ministry of Health registration system; digital radiology, intraoral-scanner and imaging software; the online appointment system and website servers; corporate email accounts; computers, backup units and authorised cloud-backup environments; accounting and electronic self-employment receipt systems; telephones and instant-messaging applications; CCTV recording devices where present; and paper-based patient registration and medical-history forms, informed-consent forms, X-ray films, contracts, accounting documents and personnel files, together with the locked cabinets and archive areas in which such documents are stored.

5. Grounds Requiring Retention and Disposal

Personal data are retained by our Practice, in particular, for (i) providing oral and dental healthcare services and keeping patient records in accordance with legislation, (ii) complying with legal obligations, (iii) evidence and defence in legal disputes, and (iv) planning and performing employee rights and obligations, within the limits specified in the Law and related legislation. Grounds requiring retention include:

  • Healthcare legislation expressly requiring patient records to be kept and retained,
  • The need to retain personal data because they are directly related to the establishment and performance of contracts,
  • Retention of personal data for the establishment, exercise or protection of a right (evidence during applicable limitation periods),
  • The need to retain personal data for the legitimate interests of our Practice, provided that the fundamental rights and freedoms of Data Subjects are not harmed,
  • Retention of personal data so that our Practice can comply with legal obligations arising from tax, social-security, occupational-health-and-safety and healthcare legislation,
  • For retention activities based on explicit consent, the continued existence of the Data Subject's explicit consent.

Under the Regulation, personal data are erased, destroyed or anonymised by our Practice ex officio or on request in the following circumstances:

  • Amendment or repeal of the relevant legislative provisions forming the basis for processing or retaining personal data,
  • Cessation of the purpose requiring the processing or retention of personal data,
  • Cessation of the conditions requiring the processing of personal data under Articles 5 and 6 of the Law,
  • Where processing is based solely on explicit consent, withdrawal of consent by the Data Subject,
  • Acceptance by our Practice of a Data Subject's request under Article 11 of the Law for erasure, destruction or anonymisation,
  • Where our Practice rejects a Data Subject's application, provides an inadequate response or fails to respond within the prescribed period, the Data Subject lodges a complaint with the Board and the Board finds the request justified,
  • Expiry of the maximum retention period without any condition justifying longer retention of the personal data.

6. Determining Retention and Disposal Periods

The following criteria are applied, in order, when determining personal-data retention and disposal periods:

  • Where legislation prescribes a retention period for the relevant personal data, that period is observed.
  • Where legislation does not prescribe a period, personal data are classified as general or special-category data on the basis of the definition in Article 6 of the Law; adequate measures determined by the Board are applied to special-category data. It is assessed whether retention complies with the principles in Article 4 of the Law and whether our Practice has a legitimate purpose for retention. The condition under Articles 5 and 6 of the Law that may justify retention is identified, and reasonable retention periods are determined in this framework, also taking into account limitation periods necessary for evidence in legal disputes.
  • For patient records, a twenty-year retention period has been determined by jointly evaluating the obligation under the Regulation on Private Healthcare Organisations Providing Oral and Dental Health Services to preserve patient records in accordance with applicable legislation, the provisions of the Regulation on Personal Health Data, limitation periods relating to the dentist's civil and criminal liability, and the patient's interest in accessing treatment history in the future.

7. Retention and Disposal Periods

Personal data processed by our Practice are retained for the periods stated below. Personal data whose retention period has expired are erased, destroyed or anonymised during the first periodic-disposal period following expiry and in any event within 180 days after the end of the retention period.

  • Patient records and medical files (patient registration and medical-history forms, examination findings, diagnosis, treatment plan and procedures performed, informed-consent forms, prescription records, radiographic images, intraoral photographs, digital impression and scan data, laboratory and prosthetic records): 20 years from the patient's last examination or treatment date. If the patient dies, health data are retained for at least 20 years from the date of death.
  • Appointment records: appointments that result in treatment are retained together with patient records as part of the patient file; online, telephone or message-based appointment requests that do not result in treatment are retained for 1 year from the date of the request.
  • Website contact-form messages and information requests: 1 year from completion of the request.
  • Explicit-consent and consent forms relating to use of patient images for informational, educational or scientific purposes: until withdrawal of consent; and for 10 years after withdrawal of consent or cessation of use for evidentiary purposes.
  • Other explicit-consent declarations (communication preferences, providing information to a patient relative, transfer to an insurance company, etc.): until withdrawal of consent; after withdrawal, for evidentiary purposes for the retention period applicable to the relevant data category.
  • Self-employment receipts, payment, accounting and tax records: 5 years starting from the calendar year following the year to which the record relates under Tax Procedure Law No. 213; where there is a legal dispute, until the dispute is finally concluded.
  • Supplier, laboratory, IT-service and other contracts and data-transfer undertakings: 10 years after termination of the contract (general limitation period under Turkish Code of Obligations No. 6098).
  • Employee personnel files, employment contracts, payroll, leave and attendance records: 10 years after termination of employment (obligations and limitation periods arising under Law No. 5510 and the Labour Law).
  • Employee health records under occupational-health-and-safety legislation (pre-employment and periodic examination reports, vaccination records): 15 years after termination of employment.
  • Job applicants' CVs and application information: 1 year from the application date; up to 2 years with the applicant's explicit consent.
  • CCTV recordings (where cameras are present in common areas of the Practice): 30 days from the recording date; recordings relating to an incident or dispute are retained until the relevant process is concluded.
  • Website and online appointment-system access and traffic logs: 2 years, in line with the maximum period prescribed for hosting providers under Law No. 5651 and on the basis of legitimate interest in Site security.
  • Data obtained through cookies: for the periods specified in the Cookie Information Notice and Cookie Policy and in any event for no more than 24 months.
  • Data Subject applications, responses and correspondence with the Board: 3 years after the application is concluded; where there is a dispute, until the dispute is concluded.
  • Patient request, complaint and satisfaction records: 3 years from creation of the record.
  • Personal data relating to a criminal offence or legal dispute: for the applicable civil or criminal limitation period.
  • Data collected under other legislation: for the period prescribed by the relevant legislation.

The periods above may not apply where the Practice's purpose for using the relevant personal data has not ended, where a retention period prescribed by applicable legislation is longer than the periods above, or where the limitation period relating to the relevant matter requires longer retention. In such cases, the period that expires later among the use purpose, specific legislation or applicable limitation period is applied.

8. Periodic Disposal

Under Article 11 of the Regulation, our Practice erases, destroys or anonymises personal data whose retention periods have expired during six-month periodic-disposal periods (June and December each year) in accordance with the procedures set out in this Policy. All operations concerning erasure, destruction and anonymisation are documented in records, and those records are retained for at least three years, without prejudice to other legal obligations.

9. Methods of Erasure, Destruction and Anonymisation

9.1. Erasure of Personal Data

In an erasure operation, the personal data subject to erasure are identified; Authorised Users for each item of personal data are determined using an access-authorisation and control matrix; and the access, retrieval and reuse permissions of those users are disabled and removed. Personal data held in HIMS, the appointment system and other databases are rendered inaccessible to Authorised Users through the relevant software's deletion command; files in server and computer environments are deleted using operating-system deletion commands and by removing access rights to the files; data in cloud-backup environments are deleted through the service provider's deletion function; and, in paper documents, the relevant personal data are rendered inaccessible to Authorised Users by irreversible redaction, crossing out, masking or erasure so that they cannot be read using technological means.

9.2. Destruction of Personal Data

During destruction, all copies containing the personal data are identified and a method appropriate to each recording medium is applied. Paper documents are irreversibly shredded using paper-destruction equipment; X-ray films and optical media are physically destroyed; data on hard drives, portable storage devices and similar magnetic or electronic media are irretrievably erased by a specialist using overwriting or magnetic-field methods, or the medium itself is physically destroyed. Devices that have reached the end of their useful life are not disposed of before the data on them have been destroyed.

9.3. Anonymisation of Personal Data

Anonymisation means preventing identification of the Data Subject by removing or modifying all direct and indirect identifiers in a data set. Where our Practice needs to use patient data for scientific studies, statistics or measurement of service quality, data are anonymised using methods such as variable removal, generalisation, masking and grouping. Under Article 28 of the Law, anonymised data fall outside the scope of the Law and explicit consent is not required to process such data for research, planning or statistical purposes.

10. Technical and Organisational Measures

The principal measures taken under Article 12 of the Law and the Board's Decision No. 2018/10 to securely retain personal data, prevent unlawful processing and access, and ensure lawful disposal include the following:

Organisational measures

  • Access to retained personal data is limited to employees who need access for their duties; when limiting access, whether the data are special-category data and their level of importance are taken into account.
  • Employees receive training on personal-data protection, patient privacy and data security and sign an Employee Confidentiality and Personal Data Protection Undertaking.
  • A Personal Data Protection Undertaking is concluded with suppliers and data processors to whom personal data are transferred, or data-security provisions are added to existing contracts.
  • A personal-data processing inventory and access-authorisation matrix are prepared and kept up to date; retention periods are tracked in the inventory.
  • Physical environments containing personal data are protected against fire, flooding, theft and similar risks; patient files and other documents are stored in locked cabinets; unauthorised access to these areas is prevented.
  • If processed personal data are obtained unlawfully by others, the incident is notified to the Board as soon as possible and no later than 72 hours, and to affected Data Subjects within the shortest reasonable period.
  • The dentist regularly audits whether the requirements of this Policy are being fulfilled.

Technical measures

  • Access to HIMS and other information systems is provided through usernames and strong passwords; user accounts are individual and are disabled immediately upon termination of employment or a change of duties.
  • Electronic environments and backups containing special categories of personal data are protected by cryptographic methods; all transaction logs concerning such data are securely maintained.
  • Data in electronic environments are backed up regularly through a secure backup system; backups are protected to the same security level, and data whose retention period has expired are also removed from backups.
  • Up-to-date antivirus software and firewalls are used; security updates are applied regularly; where remote access to special categories of personal data is required, at least two-factor authentication is applied.
  • When special categories of personal data are transferred: if transfer by email is required, data are encrypted and a corporate email address is used; if transfer by portable memory, CD, DVD or similar media is required, data are encrypted using cryptographic methods; if transfer between servers in different physical environments is required, VPN or sFTP is used; if transfer on paper is required, the document is sent in a sealed envelope marked as a confidential document.
  • Personal data are destroyed in a manner that makes them irretrievable and leaves no trace of the data; the destruction operation itself is documented in a record.

11. Responsibility and Allocation of Duties

The dentist, as Data Controller, is responsible for implementing this Policy, communicating it to employees, monitoring compliance, following legislative changes and Board decisions and updating the Policy, and carrying out periodic disposal. The dentist may appoint an employee or external service provider to perform these tasks; responsibility nevertheless remains with the Data Controller. IT service providers are responsible, under the undertakings concluded with them, for erasing and destroying personal data in their own environments in accordance with this Policy.

12. Entry into Force, Breaches and Sanctions

  • This Policy enters into force on the date it is published on our website and communicated to employees; from that date it is binding on all employees, consultants, external service providers and anyone processing personal data on behalf of our Practice.
  • The dentist is responsible for monitoring whether employees comply with the requirements of the Policy. Any conduct contrary to the Policy is reported immediately to the dentist.
  • Following an assessment, the necessary action is taken against an employee who acts contrary to the Policy within the framework of employment legislation and the Employee Confidentiality and Personal Data Protection Undertaking.
  • Our Practice reviews this Policy in line with legislative changes and Board decisions and updates it where necessary. The current version is always the version published on our website.